0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Locations
  • Gallery
BAY & GOODMAN PIZZA Logo
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Locations
  • Gallery
  • Order Online
Group Order Quick Deals Sign Up For Deals

BAY & GOODMAN PIZZA (Fairport) Online Ordering Menu

1276 FAIRPORT ROAD
Fairport, NY 14450
(585) 388-0000
11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
97% of 1,500 customers recommended
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability

Slice

Single Slice 
$3.89
1 Slice And Soda 
$5.39
2 Slice & Soda 
$9.28
Slice / 3 Garlic Knots / Soda 
$7.94
20 Oz Soda & A Slice 
$6.38
20 Oz Soda & 2 Slices 
$10.27

Jumbo Wings

Served with celery, bleu cheese, and your choice of mild buffalo, hot buffalo, country sweet, BBQ, or garlic Parmesan wing sauce.
1 Jumbo Wing 
$1.40
5 Jumbo Wings 
$6.99
10 Jumbo Wings 
$12.89
15 Jumbo Wings 
$18.75
20 Jumbo Wings 
$23.95
30 Jumbo Wings 
$35.69
50 Wings 
$55.89

Beverages

20oz Fountain Drink 
Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Sprite, Raspberry Tea, Root Beer, or Fresh Brew Tea.
$1.99
Large Chocolate Milk 
$2.78
Monster 
$2.99
20oz Bottle 
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper, or Fanta Orange.
$2.49
Flavored Drinks And Water 
$1.69
2 Liter Bottle 
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, or Dr. Pepper.
$3.29
Fairport Brewing 
$3.99

Custom Pizza

10" Pizza (Small) 
$10.99+
12" Pizza (Medium) 
$13.99+
14" Pizza (Large) 
$15.99+
16" Pizza (Extra Large) 
$17.99+
Sheet Pizza (17"x25") 
$25.99+

Boneless Wings

Served with celery, bleu cheese, and your choice of mild buffalo, hot buffalo, country sweet, BBQ, or garlic Parmesan wing sauce.
Boneless Wings 1/2 Lb  
$6.99
Boneless Wings 1 Lb  
$12.89
Boneless Wings 2 Whole Pounds  
$23.95

Shareables

Veggie Platter 
Fried mushrooms, cauliflower, and zucchini sticks with ranch dressing and our signature red sauce.
$9.99
Loaded Skins 
Russet potatoes loaded with bacon, mozzarella cheese, and sour cream.
$9.99
Mozzarella Sticks 
7 breaded mozzarella sticks with our signature red sauce.
$9.29
Bay Goodman Platter 
2 loaded skins, 2 pizza logs, 2 chicken fingers, 2 mozzarella sticks, mixed veggies, sour cream, and your choice of 2 sauces.
$16.29
Cheesy Garlic Bread 
Delicious sub loaf baked with buttery garlic Parmesan sauce, fresh herbs, and mozzarella.
$7.99
Pizza Logs 
5 pizza logs served with our signature red sauce.
$9.29
Loaded Fries 
Full lb. of tavern-style fries with bacon, mozzarella, and cheddar.
$9.99
Finger & Fries 
Generous order of tender chicken fingers with our tavern-style fries and your choice of dipping sauce.
$11.89+
Sweet Heat Chili Nachos 
Chili, cheddar jalapenos, onions, and tomatoes.
$9.99
Buffalo Chicken Nachos 
Drenched in our authentic buffalo wing sauce.
$9.99
Fried And Breaded Mushrooms 
$9.99

Classic & Specialty Pizzas

Famous Deluxe Pizza 
Our signature red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, bell peppers, and Spanish onions.
$14.99+
Garlic Garden Pizza 
Delicious garlic sauce with mozzarella, spinach, Spanish onions, and fresh tomatoes.
$14.99+
Buffalo Chicken Pizza 
Diced crispy chicken made with our authentic buffalo wing sauce topped with mozzarella. Served with bleu cheese.
$14.99+
Three Meat Pizza 
Your choice of 3 meats on our signature red sauce and mozzarella.
$14.99+
Steak Out Pizza 
Shaved sirloin steak with sauteed bell peppers, Spanish onions, and mozzarella over country sweet sauce with a touch of garlic sauce.
$14.99+
Pizza Napoli 
Thin crust with olive oil, Pecorino Romano, mozzarella, ricotta, fresh tomatoes, and basil.
$14.99+
Pizza Divinci 
Our signature red sauce with fresh tomatoes, basil, ricotta cheese, and mozzarella cheese.
$14.99+
Pizza Sicillia 
Our signature red sauce, Spanish onions, hot peppers, pepperoni, Italian sausage, and Pecorino Romano.
$14.99+
Veggie Weggie Pizza 
Our signature red sauce with mozzarella, bell peppers, mushrooms, and Spanish onions.
$14.99+
Elite Eight Pizza 
Our signature red sauce with mozzarella, pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and olives.
$14.99+
Meatball Parm Pie 
Our homemade meatballs, ricotta cheese, and mozzarella cheese with puddles of marinara sauce.
$14.99+
Chicken Bacon Ranch 
Grilled Chicken and Bacon on a layer of Buttermilk Ranch Dressing Topped with Mozzarella and more Creamy Ranch Dressing, Unbelievably Delicious
$14.99+

Great Plates

Served with your choice of sides from the following: macaroni salad, beans, home fries, French fries, or tater tots.
Hamburger Plate 
$13.89+
Cheeseburger Plate 
$13.89+
Italian Sausage Plate 
$13.89+
Steak n Cheese Plate 
$13.89+
Chicken Finger Plate 
$13.89+

Sides

French Fries (1/2 Lb) 
$4.49
Macaroni Salad 
$4.49
Home Fries 
$4.49
Side Caesar Salad 
$4.49
Side House Salad 
$4.49
House Made Chips 
$4.49
1 Garlic Knot 
$0.85
3 Garlic Knots 
$2.49
6 Garlic Knots 
$4.49
Ron's Chili 
$6.95
Tater Tots 
$4.49
Onion Rings 
$4.99
Bush's Baked Beans 
$4.99
Loaded Potato Salad 
$4.49

Calzones

All calzones are made with mozzarella and ricotta cheese.
Napoli Calzone 
Thin crust with olive oil, Pecorino Romano, mozzarella, ricotta, fresh tomatoes, and basil.
$13.95
DiVinci Calzone 
Our signature red sauce with fresh tomatoes, basil, ricotta cheese, and mozzarella cheese.
$13.95
Garlic Garden Calzone 
Delicious garlic sauce with mozzarella, spinach, Spanish onions, and fresh tomatoes.
$13.95
Sicillian Calzone 
Our signature red sauce, Spanish onions, hot peppers, pepperoni, Italian sausage, and Pecorino Romano.
$13.95
Three Meat Calzone 
Your choice of 3 meats on our signature red sauce and mozzarella.
$13.95
Buffalo Chicken Calzone 
Diced crispy chicken made with our authentic buffalo wing sauce topped with mozzarella. Served with bleu cheese.
$13.95
Veggie Weggie Calzone 
Our signature red sauce with mozzarella, bell peppers, mushrooms, and Spanish onions.
$13.95
Steak-Out Calzone 
Shaved sirloin steak with sauteed bell peppers, Spanish onions, and mozzarella over country sweet sauce with a touch of garlic sauce.
$13.95
Elite Eight Calzone 
Our signature red sauce with mozzarella, pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and olives.
$13.95
Custom Calzone 
$10.99+
Famous Deluxe Calzone 
$13.95
Pepperoni Calzone 
$13.95+

Angus Beef Perfect Burgers

6.2 Oz. (before cooking) of grill-pressed beef made fresh and served on a hard roll loaded with your favorite toppings.
Rochester Burger 
American cheese, mustard, onions, and meat hot sauce
$7.95+
All American Burger 
American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and mayo
$7.95+
Bacon Cheeseburger 
American cheese, bacon, ketchup, mustard, onions, and pickles
$8.95+
My Way Burger 
Have it your way but better...
$7.95+

Salads

House Salad 
Crisp romaine, red onions, tomatoes, red peppers, green peppers, and our house dressing.
$7.99+
Caesar Salad 
Crisp romaine, red onions, bacon, seasoned croutons, and shredded Asiago.
$8.49+
Mediterranean Salad 
Crisp romaine, roasted red peppers, red onions, artichoke hearts, black olives, and shredded Asiago.
$9.49+
Chopped Veggie Salad 
Crisp romaine, mushrooms, green peppers, carrots, tomatoes, red onions, broccoli, and our famous original Bay Goodman house vinaigrette.
$8.49+
Buffalo Chicken Salad 
$9.99+

Breakfast Pizza

Western Ham Or Bacon Peppers, Onions and Mushrooms 
A base of eggs and garlic sauce with your choice of ham or bacon and our delicious toppings
$14.99+
Italian Frittata Home fries, Italian Sausage, Peppers and Onions 
A base of eggs and our garlic sauce with our Italian Toppings
$14.99+
My Way Breakfast Pizza Up To 4 Items 
A base of eggs and garlic sauce with your choice of up to 4 delicious toppings
$14.99+

Hot Subs

Includes your choice of cheese, toppings, and dressings.
Great Steak-Out Sub 
Shaved sirloin steak, mushrooms, peppers, onions, provolone, and country sweet sauce.
$13.99+
Half Great Steak-Out Sub 
Shaved sirloin steak, mushrooms, peppers, onions, provolone, and country sweet sauce.
$7.49+
Meatball Parm Sub 
Red sauce, mozzarella, and Pecorino Romano.
$13.99+
Half Meatball Parm Sub 
Red sauce, mozzarella, and Pecorino Romano.
$7.49+
Buffalo Chicken Sub 
Crispy chicken tossed in our authentic buffalo wing sauce, covered in mozzarella cheese and bleu cheese.
$13.99+
Goodman Delite Sub 
Your choice of grilled chicken or shaved sirloin steak, with mushrooms, artichoke hearts, light garlic sauce, and provolone.
$13.99+
Half Goodman Delite Sub 
Your choice of grilled chicken or shaved sirloin steak, with mushrooms, artichoke hearts, light garlic sauce, and provolone.
$7.49+
Steak In The Grass 
Shaved sirloin steak with spinach, onions, hot banana peppers, light garlic sauce, and provolone.
$13.99+
Half Steak In The Grass 
Shaved sirloin steak with spinach, onions, hot banana peppers, light garlic sauce, and provolone.
$7.49+
Half Buffalo Chicken Sub 
Crispy chicken tossed in our authentic buffalo wing sauce, covered in mozzarella cheese and bleu cheese.
$7.49+
Chicken Finger Sub 
$13.99+
Half Chicken Finger Sub 
$7.49+
Chicken Parm Sub 
Mozzarella, red sauce, and Pecorino Romano.
$13.99+
Half Chicken Parm Sub 
Mozzarella, red sauce, and Pecorino Romano.
$7.49+
Bay Burger Sub 
Over 3/4 lb. of fresh grill-pressed burger with extra bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$13.99+
Italian Sausage 
$13.99+
Half Italian Sausage Sub 
$13.99+
My Way Cheese Steak 
Shaved sirloin steak with your choice of cheese, toppings, and dressing.
$13.99+
Half My Way Cheese Steak 
Shaved sirloin steak with your choice of cheese, toppings, and dressing.
$7.49+
Half Bay Burger Sub 
Fresh grill-pressed burger with extra bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
$7.49+
Whole My Way Hot Sub 
$8.99+

Wraps

All wraps are served with house made chips.
Garden Grill Wrap 
Mushrooms, carrots, onions, spinach, sweet peppers, artichokes, lettuce, tomatoes, mozzarella, and garlic sauce.
$8.89+
Buffalo Chicken Wrap 
Buffalo chicken, romaine, mozzarella, and blue cheese.
$9.89+
Grilled Chicken Ceasar Wrap 
Sliced grilled chicken, bacon, Asiago, lettuce, and Caesar dressing.
$9.89+
Steak Artichoke & Mushroom Wrap 
Sliced strip steak, mushrooms, artichokes, lettuce, and mozzarella.
$9.89+
Grilled Artichoke Chicken Wrap 
Sliced grilled chicken, artichokes, lettuce, and mozzarella.
$9.89+
Custom Wrap 
$8.89+
Meatball Parm Wrap 
Meatballs, mozzarella, and ricotta cheese with a side dish of marinara sauce.
$9.89+
Steak N Da Grass Wrap 
$9.89+
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap 
$9.89
LaBella Wrap 
$9.89+

Extra Sauces & Dressings

SIDE Buffalo Medium Sauce 
$0.93
SIDE Buffalo Hot Sauce 
$0.93
SIDE Buffalo Mild Sauce 
$0.93
SIDE Country Sweet 
$0.93
SIDE BBQ Sauce 
$0.93
SIDE Bleu Cheese 
$0.93
SIDE Ranch Dressing 
$0.93
SIDE House Dressing 
$0.93
SIDE Marinara 
$0.93
SIDE Garlic Parm 
$0.93
SIDE Meat Hot Sauce 
$0.93
SIDE Sour Cream 
$0.93
SIDE Chipotle Dressing 
$0.93
Extra Misc Topping Or Side 
$0.93

Cold Subs

Includes your choice of cheese, toppings, and dressings.
Italian Assorted Sub 
Hot sopressata, hot capicola, and pepperoni.
$6.95+
Old Fashion Assorted Sub 
Turkey, ham, and salami.
$6.95+
Turkey Sub 
$6.95+
Baked Ham Sub 
$6.95+
Hot Soppressata Sub 
$6.95+
Cappicola Sub 
$6.95+
Tuna Sub 
$6.95+
Veggie Sub 
$6.95+
Cheese Sub 
$6.95+

Grilled Panini

All paninis are served with our house made chips.
Pisano Panini 
Hot sopressata, tomato, roasted peppers, provolone, and our house made oil.
$9.89+
Wise Guy Panini 
House-made meatballs, capicola, mozzarella, and provolone brushed with extra virgin olive oil.
$9.89+
Bambino Panini 
Roasted turkey, bacon, provolone, and ranch dressing.
$9.89+
Margherita Panini 
Fresh tomato, basil, mozzarella, and extra virgin olive oil.
$8.89+
La Bella Panini 
Fresh spinach, tomatoes, Asiago, and mozzarella.
$8.89+
The My Way Panini 
$6.89+
Grilled Artichoke Chicken Panini 
Sliced grilled chicken, artichokes, lettuce, and mozzarella.
$9.89+
Grilled Cheese Sandwich 
$4.99
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato Sandwich 
$8.89+

Catered Shareables, Salads & Deli Trays

Garlic Knots (24) 
Smothered in garlic sauce with Parmesan cheese and a side of marinara sauce.
$15.95
Loaded Potato Skins (18) 
$29.95
50 Chicken Wings 
Served with celery, bleu cheese, and your favorite wing sauce.
$52.50
100 Wings 
Served with celery, bleu cheese, and your favorite wing sauce.
$99.99
House Potato Chips 1/2 Pan 
$17.95
House Salad 1/2 Pan 
Crisp romaine, red onions, tomatoes, red peppers, green peppers, and our house dressing.
$24.95
Caesar Salad 1/2 Pan 
Crisp romaine, red onions, bacon, seasoned croutons, and shredded Asiago.
$24.95
Macaroni Salad 1/2 Pan 
$29.95
Chef's Salad (1/2 Pan) 
Crisp romaine, ham, turkey, provolone, and our house dressing.
$32.95
Sub Tray 12 pcs. 
Your choice of our delicious cold subs with condiments
$34.95
Sub Tray 16 pcs 
Your choice of our delicious cold subs with condiments
$49.95
Wrap Tray 12 pcs 
Tomato and garlic herb wraps with your choice of cold cuts and cheese.
$34.95
Wrap Tray 18 pcs 
Tomato and garlic herb wraps with your choice of cold cuts and cheese.
$42.95
Mediterranean Salad 
$36.95
Loaded Potato Salad 
$29.95

Ice Cream

Freeze Pops 
$0.46
Cookies & Cream / Cotton Candy 
$1.79
Super Sundaes 
$1.49
Ice Cream Sandwich 
$1.49
Moose Tracks Cone 
$1.89
P Nutty Cone 
$1.29
Incredible 
$1.89

Desserts

Pizza Fritta (fried dough) 
Your choice of either cinnamon sugar or powdered sugar
$4.29
Brownie 
$4.49
Cannolis (Made To Order) 
2 delicious cheese cannolis
$4.99
Chocolate Chunk Cookie 
4.5oz triple chocolate chunk cookie
$2.49
Gala Apple 
$0.75
Frosted Cupcakes 
2 buttercream frosted vanilla and chocolate cakes
$4.49
Reese's Peanut Butter Cookies 
4.5oz PB cup chunk cookie
$2.99
Hot Apple Logs (2 W/Cinnamon Sugar & Icing) 
2 apple logs rolled in cinnamon sugar with a side of icing
$4.49

Delivery Fee

Close Delivery Surcharge 
$2.00
Delivery Surcharge 
$4.00
Delivery Surcharge 
$6.00

Fish Fry

11 oz Battered Haddock, Homemade Coleslaw, French fries, Tartar, Ketchup and Lemon
Haddock Fish Fry 
$13.79
Fish Wedges & Fries 
$9.99
Your cart is empty.
Powered by Menufy © 2021
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.